Civil Writ – Property Law - Urban Land Ceiling – Proceedings Abated – De Facto Possession Not Taken – State Failed to Prove Physical Possession - State failed to establish that actual possession was taken prior to repeal of the Urban Land Ceiling Act – No documentary proof of possession, panchnama, or memorandum of possession produced – Petitioners continued in ...
Civil Writ - Rejection of application filed under Section 32 of the Bihar Consolidation Act - Consolidation Proceedings – Effect of Completion Without Formal Denotification – Collector Rightly Declined Jurisdiction - Court held that once the Draft Scheme under Section 13(1) is finalized and certificates are issued under Section 15, and the scheme is confirmed under Section 16, the cons...
Arbitration – Power to Grant Interest – Clause 22 – No Express Bar on Pendente Lite Interest – The clause barring the contractor from claiming interest on payments, arrears or balances due does not amount to an express bar on the arbitrator’s power to award pendente lite interest – Held: Under the 1940 Act, absence of a specific prohibition on the arbitrator&rsq...
Matrimonial Law - Permanent Alimony – Requirement of Formal Application – Mandatory – The Trial Court awarded permanent alimony to the respondent-wife under Section 25 of the Hindu Marriage Act without there being any formal or oral application by the wife – Held: In view of binding precedents of Madhya Pradesh High Court, including Abhishek Parashar v. Neha Parashar, it is...
Civil Writ - Challenge to Selection Process – Alleged Irregularities in Evaluation – Dismissed – Petitioners contended that there were discrepancies in marks, improper scaling, and procedural irregularities – Court held that the selection process was conducted as per rules and in absence of specific material irregularities, challenge was liable to be rejected [Paras 39-48]....
Arbitration – Interim Award on Limitation – Premature Decision without Evidence – Found Contrary to Fundamental Policy - Arbitrator decided limitation issue as preliminary issue solely on demurrer relying only on claimant's pleadings – Arbitrator himself noted that with evidence the outcome might differ – Held: Decision violates judicial approach requirement under...
Labour Law – Bonus – Applicability of Payment of Bonus Act, 1965 – Appellant trust engaged in rehabilitation of leprosy-cured and specially-abled persons – Since 1985 also engaged in commercial manufacturing of automobile and industrial parts generating profits – Workers, though beneficiaries of rehabilitation, employed in manufacturing activities in factories covered...
Limitation – Applicability of Extended Limitation due to COVID-19 – Petition and Appeal held to be within time - Appellant’s original petition filed during the Covid-19 limitation relaxation period as per Supreme Court directions – The Appeal filed within 90 days as provided by Section 28(4) of the Hindu Marriage Act was also within limitation despite Section 19(3) of Famil...
Consumer Rights – Service Charge in Restaurants – Guidelines under CPA, 2019 – Upheld – CCPA guidelines prohibiting mandatory levy of service charge held valid – The Court upheld the guidelines issued by CCPA barring mandatory collection of service charge, observing that such charges cannot be imposed coercively, and must be voluntary – Held: Such mandatory coll...
Matrimonial Law - Divorce – Mental Cruelty – Husband's Disinterest in Marital Relationship – Divorce Granted - The wife alleged that the husband was indifferent towards family life, abstained from conjugal relations, and was engrossed in superstitious and spiritual practices – Evidence proved that despite earlier reconciliation, the husband continued neglecting the peti...
